Tips for City Managers: Collecting Data for the Unmet Needs Assessment
Community Development Block Grant Disaster Recovery (CDBG-DR) Program
A/./ neighborhood under water after Hurricane Harvey blasted through the southern U.S. in August 2017.
Whether your city is a grantee or subgrantee of a CDBG-DR award, you will be required to complete an unmet needs assessment to help prioritize your recovery projects and determine how your funding will be allocated to housing, economic development, and infrastructure recovery projects.
City managers play a key role in coordinating with emergency management, county officials, and other community leaders to ensure a systematic, comprehensive assessment of the county’s unmet needs. Based on experience conducting unmet needs assessments across the country, IBTS provides the following advice for city managers tasked with collecting unmet needs assessment data.
Begin collecting data on damage as soon as the disaster subsides.
- Coordinate with your emergency management agency and county staff to collect information and put a dollar amount on as much storm damage as possible to sectors like homes, local business, infrastructure, loss of life, and more.
Designate an individual or team to collect and systematically record data.
- City managers may be responsible for leading data collection, however it often requires an all-hands-on-deck approach. Emergency managers, county administrators, local NGOs and charitable organizations, and the religious community can also assist.
- Use HUD‘s data collection requirements, which can be found in the Federal Register notice for your award, to develop an organizational plan for your assessment.
Develop and implement a public outreach plan.
- Canvassing door-to-door to speak with homeowners individually can provide the most in-depth, accurate data.
- When speaking with homeowners, ask them about other damage such as to their business, vehicles, second properties, etc., in addition to their homes.
- Use all available methods of communication, including social media, local news outlets, public service announcements, and town hall meetings.
- Encourage local nonprofits, the religious community, and other NGOs to ask their members for unmet needs.
Target specific sectors of your community.
- Some religious, economic, racial, non-English speaking, or ethnic sectors may be less willing to share their needs or reach out for help.
- Communicate with these groups individually, such as by canvassing to areas with a high density of one or more of these populations. If possible, send a team member who can break down communication barriers and empathize with these citizens.
Engage the local religious community, NGOs, and nonprofits.
- Reach out to local religious leaders for data – oftentimes residents will report damage to the leader of their congregation, but not to the local government.
- Set up a table at local religious institutions to talk with community members on their way in and out of services.
- Include leaders from these organizations on your unmet needs assessment team, and make sure they are representative of the diverse populations that exist within your city.
Implement a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with FEMA, the Small Business Administration, insurers, and other local agencies as quickly as possible.
- Ideally, the city or city emergency management agency should have MOUs in place before a disaster hits. If not, implement them as soon as possible to ensure you have access to available data sources.
- Have this HUD sample form for requesting data from FEMA on hand to expedite the data retrieval process.
- Don’t forget to have MOUs or similar agreements in place with local churches, insurers, NGOs, and other nonprofits.
Track assistance received from other sources to avoid duplication of benefits.
- Your unmet needs assessment cannot include needs that have already been covered by other sources of assistance, such as FEMA, SBA, insurance, and local or national charities.
- Your unmet needs can include projects that other disaster assistance has not been applied to, or to fulfill the remaining need on projects that other assistance has been applied to but only for a portion of the cost.
- For example:
- If your city incurs $60 million in home damage, but homeowners’ insurance has already covered $40 million, your unmet need is only $20 million.
- If five bridges are damaged but FEMA provides assistance to repair three of them, CDBG-DR funds can be used to repair the remaining two.
See the links below to find more resources and information from HUD on conducting an unmet needs assessment.
CDBG-DR Duplication of Benefits Webinar
Data Sources: Disaster Impact and Unmet Needs Assessment Kit – Appendix C
